- Jean-Luc Brunel was poised to cooperate with U.S. prosecutors in 2016 with evidence on Epstein.
- Epstein learned of the negotiations and intervened before Brunel could talk.
- This blocked a potential investigation for three more years.
- More than 50 additional girls were trafficked during this delay.
- Brunel was later arrested and found dead in his Paris prison cell.
A potential breakthrough in holding Jeffrey Epstein accountable was quietly sabotaged in 2016, allowing the financier’s sex-trafficking operation to continue victimizing young women for three more critical years. This revelation comes from newly released Justice Department files that detail how French modeling agent Jean-Luc Brunel, a central figure in Epstein’s network, was on the verge of cooperating with federal prosecutors before suddenly going silent.
The files show that in February 2016, Brunel’s lawyer was negotiating with attorneys for Epstein’s victims. The goal was a meeting with the U.S. Attorney’s office in Manhattan where Brunel would provide information in exchange for immunity. Handwritten notes by a federal prosecutor state clearly: "One of Epstein’s bfs, Jean Luc Brunel, has helped get girls. He is wanting to cooperate." The notes add that Brunel was "afraid of being prosecuted" and possessed "photographic evidence."
A deal vanishes
Brunel’s lawyer indicated his client had recruited girls for Epstein and held incriminating photos. A date for Brunel to walk into the prosecutor’s office was discussed. Then, all communication stopped.
The files indicate Epstein learned of the negotiations. On May 3, 2016, Epstein emailed attorney Kathy Ruemmler, a former top Obama administration official. He warned that Brunel planned to approach prosecutors the following week and revealed a critical detail: one of Brunel’s friends had "asked for 3 million dollars so that Jean Luc would not go in." Epstein dismissed Brunel’s associates as "scammers" and wrote, "I want to know more."
Ruemmler replied hours later asking Epstein to call and explain. The next day she wrote, "Awake now. Talking to Poe in 20 mins," referencing Gregory Poe, Epstein’s Washington lawyer. Poe has said he did not speak with Ruemmler or Epstein about Brunel "on May 4, 2016 or at any other time." A spokesperson for Ruemmler said the email was "another instance of Epstein attempting to engage Ms. Ruemmler on a matter about which she had no knowledge."
Why Brunel ultimately refused to cooperate remains unclear, as does whether any money changed hands. What is documented is the devastating consequence. No investigation was opened. The prosecutor’s notes were later redacted in a government filing. A spokesman for the U.S. Attorney’s office in Manhattan declined to comment.
The cost of silence
Epstein remained free until his arrest in July 2019. "It set us back a couple of years," said David Boies, an attorney for Epstein victims. "We know from our lawsuits that there were more than 50 girls that were trafficked after this."
Brunel was no minor player. He ran MC2 Model Management, an agency prosecutors say acted as a pipeline for victims. Epstein wired up to $1 million to launch it. Brunel used the agency to recruit foreign girls, secure work visas, and provide a facade of legitimate employment. He traveled on Epstein’s jet, visited his island, and was in near-constant contact.
Joseph Titone, Brunel’s attorney, said he advised his client to cut ties. "I recommended and advised him to stop communicating with Epstein, but he never did," Titone said. The breach between the two men in early 2016, which included a lawsuit filed by Brunel against Epstein, proved temporary. They settled confidentially.
The Justice Department did not move against Epstein until after a Miami Herald investigation in late 2018 renewed scrutiny. When Epstein was arrested, Brunel and Ghislaine Maxwell were named co-conspirators. Brunel was arrested in France in 2020 on related allegations. He was found dead in his prison cell in 2022.
The story that emerges from these documents is one of a missed turning point. In 2016, a man with direct knowledge and evidence of a vast trafficking operation was ready to talk. That path was blocked, and a simple, grim transaction was suggested: silence for $3 million. For the dozens of young women victimized in the years that followed, the price of that silenced testimony was immeasurably higher. It is a lesson in how justice delayed is not merely justice denied, but an invitation for further cruelty.
Sources for this article include:
Please contact us for more information.